
A Tale of Two Pardons
by CJ Waldron
The power to grant pardons is one of the most powerful weapons in the presidential arsenal. It has been used to correct long ago decided wrongs, those convicted of possessing a small amount of marijuana under the archaic drug policies enacted by the Nixon Administration. It has also been used to pardon family members, political allies and even relatives of the First Family.
There have been many controversial uses of a president’s pardon power. The pardoning of Confederate soldiers and Vietnam War Draft evaders stand out. Up until recently, the most controversial pardon was that of Richard Nixon following the Watergate incident, which resulted in him becoming the only president to resign from office.
The Recent Pardons
Yet it is the most recent use of presidential pardon power that has drawn the most scrutiny. Many are viewing these recent actions by both the present and previous administrations as abuses of the pardon power. And some are even demanding changes to the process that has been in place since George Washington’s administration.
When Joe Biden issued a pardon for his son Hunter, there was an outcry from both sides of the political aisles. Many accused him of going back on his promise not to pardon his son, who was convicted of tax evasion and illegal gun possession. His defenders responded by asking, “What father wouldn’t come to their son’s defense?” His actions were further justified when Republican lawmakers vowed to continue to investigate the younger Biden, even despite the pardon.
In the waning days of his presidency, Biden issued more presidential pardons, this time to Dr. Anthony Fauci, General Mark Milley and members of the Committee Investigation January 6th. Each of them had been targeted for retribution by the incoming Trump administration and the pardons were seen as a measure to protect them from right-wing persecution.
Again there was outrage from the MAGA faction of the Republican Party, which was pretty much the entire party now that it has been transformed into the Party of Trump. They viewed these pardons as a slap in the face to their efforts to punish those who sought to hold Trump accountable for his actions during the COVID pandemic and the January 6th insurrection. They have even formed their own committee to investigate January 6th with the aim of rewriting the history of that fateful day while pledging to investigate the investigators who highlighted Donald Trump’s actions as they related to the event.
Following up on the Republican threat to go after the “Biden Crime Family”, even after he had left office, President Biden issued a final set of pardons that prevented such retribution, much( to the dismay of the MAGA cult.
While controversial, these pardons were far from extraordinary. Democrats claimed that Biden reneged on his promise to not pardon his son. They saw it as further damaging what was being viewed as a tarnished legacy following his late withdrawal from the presidential race which they say emboldened Trump supporters and led to the defeat of Kamala Harris.
Republicans were angered because they had envisioned the next four years as a way of rewriting history to the advantage of Donald Trump. They dreamed of multiple trials were Biden and his cohorts would be publicly humiliated and ultimately punished for their roles in damaging the MAGA label. While those pardoned will almost certainly be called upon to testify before the sham January 6th committee, the pardons make it nearly impossible to issue any form of punishment.
Trump has even given Biden a “gift” of sorts. When he successfully argued that presidents have immunity, he effectively provided Biden with a ready-made defense should Republicans try to hold him accountable for any imagined transgressions.
Seeking Retribution
When Donald Trump assumed office, he wasted no time seeking to punish those who opposed him while rewarding those who supported his illegal attempts to remain in office. He revoked the security clearances of those he saw as not backing him. He fired or laid off those who had policies that were contrary to his MAGA agenda. And most controversial, he issued a blanket pardon to almost fifteen hundred individuals who were either convicted or faced trial for their participation in the January 6th insurrection.
Democrats were quick to denounce the move, but the Republican reaction made it clear they were caught off guard by Trump’s swift action, despite his campaign promise that he would “look into it” on Day One of his administration. A few, like Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, condemned the move. Others, like former Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, who was ultimately responsible for Donald Trump’s return to the White House due to his refusal to prosecute him for the crimes of January 6th, indicated that Trump had gone too far by releasing even the most violent offenders.
His defenders employed a variety of strategies to explain away Trump’s actions. Some said that it was simply a matter of “Promises made, promises kept” since he made the frequent campaign promise of freeing the “patriots” of January 6th. They conveniently ignore the fact that this promise was that he would “review” the January 6th cases before deciding who would receive a pardon.
Rather than take the time going through the arduous review process, Trump took the lazy approach and allegedly said, “F*ck it! Pardon them all”. This resulted in even the most dangerous criminals being released. Some have already threatened revenge leaving even family members fearful. One has even been re-arrested on a weapons charge.
Others, such as Alabama’s Tommy (Dumb as a Box of Rocks) Tuberville, employed the strategy used by the proverbial three monkeys (See no Evil, Hear no Evil, Speak no Evil) by claiming he never saw, heard or read anything related to January 6th.
Senate Majority Leader John Thune employed an equally lame defense. Rather than taking a stand, he used the childish defense, “Well, he did it first!” meaning Trump was justified in granting the pardons due to Biden’s actions. His twisted reasoning equated the release of violent criminals with those who had been unfairly targeted for nothing more than political revenge.
The Party of Law and Order
Republicans have always claimed to be the party of Law and Order. During the 2020 election, they touted “Back the Blue” while declaring that Democrats wanted to Defund the Police in wake of the Black Lives Matter protests that followed the murder of George Floyd. So members of the Fraternal Order of Police, who had backed Trump each time he ran, were shocked when news of the pardons was revealed. Current and former members of the Capitol Police, some of whom were victims of the very people being set free, were outraged by the report.
Making the situation even worse, some Republicans have invited the freed insurrectionists to visit the Capitol. It’s like returning to the scene of a crime, but as a guest. Others are trying to set up a visit to the White House including a possible photo op with Trump.
It’s enough to make your head explode with outrage!
Republicans, and even some Democrats, are trying to claim the pardons are the same. But it is like comparing apples to oranges. Biden’s use of the pardon power would not have been necessary if the people to whom they were issued weren’t being targeted for retribution. Trump, on the other hand, had no other reason than to flex his political muscle. He is demonstrating what a presidency without consequences will be like.
It’s going to be a long four years!
CJ Waldron, a long-time contributor to Lean to the Left, is adjunct English professor at Horry-Georgetown Technical College in Conway, SC, and co-author of Hijacked Nation, Donald Trump’s attack on America’s greatness, now available at Amazon and Barnes & Noble.